Mafia Discussion Thread

I'll explain more when I get home, but:

I was basically the middle-man for Yoshi and Jon. I knew the identity of everyone except Kurtle, Dark, and Cookie.

Then Cookie tricked me into thinking he was the vigilante. I mistakenly trusted him due to how confused he seemed.

Basically, he would kill Kurtle, Jon would investigate Dark, and then we'd vote for Dark or Mira based on that.

So to put it simply: Cookie is an evil genius.

But damn it Yoshi, I told you to delay protecting till I got home. >.<

EDIT: And I mainly used IRC to contact people, not PMs. I also had a .txt file listing people's identities and such that I put on Dropbox, so Jon could get updates throughout the day if I didn't go on IRC.

EDIT2: I'm too lazy to rewrite all this, so...

 IRC Talk With Xela

[15:37] <+BTA> :<
[15:37] * +BTA is back home
[15:37] <+BTA> Xela?
[15:37] <Lord_Xela> Hmm?
[15:37] <+BTA> what did you want to know about? :p
[15:38] <Lord_Xela> I wanted to know about something?
[15:38] <+BTA> you asked about what exactly went on, communication wise
[15:38] <Lord_Xela> Yeah.
[15:38] <Lord_Xela> I was asking that you post it.
[15:38] <Lord_Xela> Because I was curious.
[15:38] <+BTA> I posted some of it
[15:39] <+BTA> and I'll post more that I'm back home, but...
[15:39] <Lord_Xela> But?
[15:39] <+BTA> basically, Jon investigated me
[15:39] <+BTA> which lead to him contacting me
[15:39] <+BTA> then we started working together
[15:39] <+BTA> this was after the whole CoB and MasPan thing, though
[15:40] <+BTA> due to their trust as well as Jon's, I was able to act as the middle-man
[15:40] <+Holypie> You forgot me :<
[15:40] <+BTA> Yoshi revealed his identity to me, as you probably know
[15:40] <+BTA> yes, Holypie too, sorry ;_;
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> And this is the exact example of supermasonry that I was worried about.
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> Granted.
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> You guys executed it poorly.
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> <_<
[15:41] <+BTA> how so?
[15:41] <+BTA> if this is about Mira
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> With that much info you should have known who to go for. <_>
[15:41] <+BTA> we didn't vote her because we weren't sure if she was God Father
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> At least, that's what it seems like to me.
[15:41] * Lord_Xela shrugs.
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> Yes.
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> I know.
[15:41] <+BTA> we didn't know about Kurtle, Dark, or Cookie
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> And you knew Will was the thief.
[15:41] <+BTA> Cookie was how we lost
[15:41] <Lord_Xela> I didn't make it clear enough, I guess.
[15:42] <Lord_Xela> That the thief didn't count towards the mafia's numbers for the win condition.
[15:42] <+BTA> ...it was brought up multiple times, in front of you, that we thought the thief was part of the 25% that was mafia :<
[15:42] <+BTA> anyway
[15:42] <+BTA> Cookie SOMEHOW posed as the vigilante
[15:43] <+BTA> and by SOMEHOW I mean
[15:43] <+BTA> ...he could barely type
[15:43] <Lord_Xela> <_<
[15:43] <+BTA> he was confused about the rules
[15:43] <+BTA> he didn't even know that you could share identities
[15:43] <+BTA> ...so I believed him
[15:43] <+BTA> he was going to kill Kurtle, Jon would investigate Dark, and then we'd vote Dark or Mira
[15:43] <Lord_Xela> Heh.
[15:44] <+BTA> ...but uh, because Yoshi's not here, I have to ask you this
[15:44] <Lord_Xela> Good going on his part.
[15:44] <+BTA> ...did you make him send in a night action? :<
[15:44] <Lord_Xela> Who? Yoshi?
[15:44] <+BTA> I asked him to delay in doing so, because I wanted to make sure I had time to look at the clues
[15:44] <Lord_Xela> Oh.
[15:44] <Lord_Xela> No, I pestered no one for actions.
[15:44] <+BTA> so imagine my surprise when I wake up and we already lost >.<
[15:44] <Lord_Xela> Not that I recall, anyway.
[15:44] <+BTA> I mean, sure
[15:45] <+BTA> we probably wouldn't have solved the clues anyway
[15:45] <+BTA> ...but yeah
[15:46] <+Berzerk> Woo
[15:46] <+BTA> anyway
[15:46] <+BTA> was a lot of fun
[15:46] <+Berzerk> I never though in a million years
[15:46] <+BTA> but I have to ask
[15:46] <+Berzerk> I'd get stuck in a login loop like a Private server
[15:46] <+Berzerk> On GMS.
[15:46] <+BTA> how the hell did you expect us to play without doing "supermasonry"
[15:46] <+BTA> :<
[15:46] <+BTA> I liked doing that
[15:46] <Lord_Xela> Oh I don't know.
[15:46] <+BTA> made the most sense
[15:46] <Lord_Xela> The clues, maybe?
[15:46] <Lord_Xela> <_<
[15:46] <Lord_Xela> Or by talking openly in public.
[15:46] <+BTA> ...we're not smart, Xela
[15:46] <Lord_Xela> Like the town should do.
[15:46] <+BTA> I thought you would have realized that by now ;_;
[15:46] <+BTA> I did that too
[15:46] <Lord_Xela> They aren't supposed to be the sneaky secretive ones.
[15:47] <Lord_Xela> That's the mafia's jorb.
[15:47] <+BTA> didn't you notice how I was always truthful?
[15:47] * Lord_Xela shrugs.
[15:47] <+BTA> hell, even when I lied about my name to CoB, I wasn't really lying
[15:47] <Lord_Xela> <_<
[15:47] <+BTA> I said my name was Jesse, because he was always the innocent one in the stories
[15:47] <+BTA> ...my real first name is Jesse :p
[15:48] <Lord_Xela> lulz.