2014-05-27, 07:50 PM
y0y0y0y0shi0 Wrote:I'd say there's a good chance a portion of the mafia is within the quieter members. On the same thread, however, we should look at the results of yesterday's lynching.
Words was lynched by Zelkova and Verrkol. Good chance mafia is within those 2, if not both. I'm still /heavily/ leaning towards Verrkol there, but I'm certainly not ruling out Zelkova. But that's Island A and I can't really do anything there yet.
Sega was lynched by MasPan and Holypie. In retrospect, I suppose it was fairly obvious MasPan was a survivor. Less so than Sega or Words might have been, but still fairly obvious. And I'm still inclined to believe that Holypie is a survivor, albeit possibly just overager?
I'd say our best bets for Island B are MetaSeraphim/ImagineAll currently. I could very well be wrong, but it's not like I have much to directly go on here.
Words was lynched more because of inactivity on island A than anything else. I frankly never expected a "successful" lynch with only 2 votes and returned too late to stop it. It's easy to cast myself or Zelkova as mafia with 20-20 hindsight but remember that no one except Olsi ever defended Words and we literally had no other suspicious candidate. Don't forget that others voted for Words throughout the day only to retract them later.
Your defense of Holypie is inconsistent logically if voting to lynch is your only evidence of pirate behavior.
I've probably done more than anyone else on las islas de muertas to analyze our fellows and search logically for pirate scum.
As for Corn's situation, it could be a continual use of power rather than a permanent one. It does seem pirate-esque to target him for vote retribution (mmm popcorn) so I'm inclined towards his innocence.
Polantaris substituting for his twin brother Dusk could swing either way, but I'm inclined towards his innocence.
Olsi seems obviously innocent and I'm most confident about him on either island.
Our other silent compatriots are far more suspicious along with Zelkova and Holypie for lynch voting. Others may include myself in this category but I'll pointlessly state that I am not a pirate and I've already presented my defense besides.
I'll avoid singling someone out for lynching for now so I don't contribute to another fiasco like yesterday.